The Digital Divide: Why Inclusion Is a Public Service Problem

We explore how the rapid migration of public services online is leaving millions of Londoners unable to access the support they need; and why Lifelong Learning providers are quietly becoming the implementation layer that government digital transformation depends on.

There is an assumption embedded in the government’s drive toward digital public services: that the people who need those services can access them. It is an assumption that is incorrect for nearly one in five UK adults.

The shift to digital-first public services is not in itself the issue. Greater efficiency, reduced cost and improved access for the majority are genuine gains. But efficiency for some is exclusion for others; and the gap between the ambition of government digital transformation and the reality of who it leaves behind has become a pressing policy failure.

The scale of digital exclusion

Research published in June 2026 by the Digital Poverty Alliance found that one in five UK adults cannot access or use essential digital government services without assistance from a friend, family member or charity. That is approximately 19 million people for who Universal Credit, NHS appointments, Pension Credit, eVisas, school admissions and a host of other critical services present a significant barrier.

The profile of those excluded is consistent across every major dataset. Older people are disproportionately represented; those over 85 are eight times more likely to be non-users of the internet than the general population. 2.7 million people aged 65 and over do not use the internet at all. People on low incomes, those with disabilities, and those with lower levels of formal education face compounding barriers that digital transformation, in its current form, has not been designed to address.

The government’s DWP data is particularly telling. Of those claiming Attendance Allowance, 46% said they would need to rely on others to apply for or manage their benefits online. Among Pension Credit customers, 36% were currently offline altogether. These are not marginal groups. They are the people for whom public services exist.

When efficiency becomes exclusion

For local authorities, this challenge is becoming more urgent. Changes to local government funding, including the Fair Funding Review, are adding to the pressure on councils to find efficiencies, with digital-first services offering one potential solution.

Yet this creates a difficult tension. Adult learning services, which are not statutory requirements in the same way as many other council services, can find themselves vulnerable to funding pressures, despite providing the digital skills and confidence that residents need to access services online. Reducing investment in this provision risks undermining the very efficiencies that digital transformation is intended to deliver.

The House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee, reporting in 2023, was direct in its concern: the shift toward digital-by-default public services had not been accompanied by adequate support for those who struggled with digital access. Libraries and community organisations had absorbed additional responsibilities without the resources or training to meet them. Too many online services had poor accessibility for those with additional needs. And provision for those who could not, or did not wish to, use online services was being quietly dismantled.

The 10 Year Health Plan for England, published in 2025, doubles down on digital transformation; placing the NHS App at the centre of how people will access health services. The government’s 2025 Digital Inclusion Action Plan acknowledges the challenge this creates. But acknowledgement is not the same as resolution. For every additional service that migrates online without a corresponding investment in digital confidence, the gap between policy intent and lived experience widens.

The Centre for Ageing Better captures the tension: as daily life becomes ever more digitally driven – from booking a GP appointment to paying for a bus ticket – the risk of exclusion for those who are not online intensifies with every iteration of the transformation agenda.

Confidence, not connectivity, is the real barrier

It is tempting to frame digital exclusion as primarily an infrastructure problem; the constraints of broadband access, device availability and affordability. But the evidence consistently points to something less tangible as the primary barrier. It is confidence.

The NHS’s own framework for digital inclusion is unambiguous on this point: around 10 million adults in the UK lack basic digital skills, shaped by factors including literacy, language, income, age and disability. The NHS framework identifies “friendly, trusted support in community settings where people feel comfortable” as the most effective route to overcoming those barriers.

Good Things Foundation’s expert overview of basic digital skills reaches the same conclusion: formal, publicly-funded qualification courses have low take-up, and work only for a minority of those who face digital skills barriers. The routes that actually reach people are informal, community-based and relationship-led. They are, in other words, the model that Lifelong Learning already operates.

Tackling digital exclusion could generate over £1.1 billion in annual savings to the public sector alone, through reduced demand on face-to-face and telephone services.

The Centre for Economics and Business Research

Policy and practice: the implementation gap

The government needs digital inclusion to succeed. Its efficiency savings, its NHS transformation agenda, its welfare reform programme – all of it depends on the assumption that people can engage with services online. The Centre for Economics and Business Research has estimated that tackling digital exclusion could generate over £1.1 billion in annual savings to the public sector alone, through reduced demand on face-to-face and telephone services.

The evidence is unambiguous that what works is local, trusted, face-to-face support; delivered by people who know their communities and can meet individuals where they are, rather than where policy assumes them to be.

This is the implementation gap that Lifelong Learning fills. Across London’s boroughs, digital skills provision is already reaching the residents that the government’s transformation agenda most depends on; older adults who cannot book their GP online, benefit claimants who cannot navigate Universal Credit, ESOL learners for whom English-language digital interfaces present a double barrier. They are not being reached by national programmes. They are being reached by local lifelong learning providers, in community settings.

A provision that pays for itself

The economics of this provision are straightforward. Every resident who gains the confidence to manage their benefits, book health appointments or access council services online reduces demand on the telephone and face-to-face channels that cost significantly more to operate. Every older adult who can use the NHS App independently represents a marginal saving that, multiplied across a borough’s population, becomes material.

But the return is broader than cost efficiency. Digital confidence connects directly to the wider themes of wellbeing, independence and social participation that run through lifelong learning. Research consistently finds that older adults who engage with digital tools report reduced isolation, greater independence and improved mental wellbeing. The skills that allow someone to video-call a grandchild are the same skills that allow them to manage a prescription renewal. They are not separate outcomes. They are the same intervention.

A layer government cannot afford to lose

National data published by the Department for Education shows that participation in digital skills provision across the adult learning sector rose by 9.7% in 2024/25, to 47,410 learners; a meaningful increase, driven in significant part by community and lifelong learning routes.

The direction of sentiment is encouraging. The government’s 2025 Digital Inclusion Action Plan, the NHS’s own framework for inclusive digital healthcare, and the renewed emphasis on local accountability across skills and employment policy all point toward a recognition that community-based provision is not peripheral to the transformation agenda; it is integral to it.

That recognition, translated into sustained support for the local infrastructure already delivering results, is what will determine whether digital inclusion moves from aspiration to reality.

More from Wellbeing & Work

Let the People Sing

Lifelong learning is the unsung hero of the educational landscape but it’s tricky to prove when data about the beneficial impacts can be so difficult to capture explains Caroline McDonald from HOLELX. Interview by Nicola Baird.

Learning how to make money go further in everyday life

Practical learning can have an immediate impact on people’s everyday lives. Building confidence with budgeting, spending and basic maths skills helps learners make informed decisions, reduce stress and improve financial stability.

The Art of Goal Keeping

Simon Parkinson, CEO of the large adult learning charity, WEA, looks at the multiple pluses lifelong learning courses give adults – something that gets lost in translation by a government that still has no overall adult learning strategy. Interview by Nicola Baird.

Subscribe for Updates

What are you looking for?

One thing remains constant. That London changes at pace.

Subscribe to the newsletter and receive regular insight updates.

Receive our newsletter sent six times a year – sharing articles, interviews and perspectives from across London’s adult and community learning network.